GreatFlorida Homeowner's Insurance®

Susan Malota

Mar 14, 2024

Efficiency, Amy is all about efficiency! She gets the job done, I appreciate that I can email her anytime and she gets it done ✔️ She is the best!

Annette Kidder

Feb 28, 2024

Amy Nuttall is the best! She is friendly, professional, efficient, and provides helpful feedback. We are very happy with our new insurance and would recommend Amy to our friends and family!

John “Jack” O'Donnell

Dec 14, 2023

I've been using this agency in St. Augustine for a long stretch. I do recommend them. Excellent rates, dependable, and very knowledgable.

Kayla Brass

Nov 28, 2023

Customer did not leave a comment...

David Wohl

Nov 06, 2023

Agent, Amy Nuttall, is very pleasant and professional. She expeditiously researched and executed a suitable insurance policy for my home. She returned calls promptly and answered all questions clearly and precisely. This is the type of agent I respect and like to do business with.

Micheline B

Feb 17, 2023

As my insurance premium was going through the roof, Amy has been determined to find a more reasonable carrier, and she did, half the premium I was paying. Great Florida Insurance has your back, and is best.

Barbara Horton

Jan 31, 2023

I have used this company for many years and Amy has always been so helpful!!

Bob Pelletier

Jan 05, 2023

Amy wzs prompt in her responses, amical to deal with and quite professional 😀

Nancy Burnett

Mar 30, 2022

Amy Nuttal is so helpful & a pleasure to work with!

Mike Onell

Oct 26, 2021

Great agency. Any issues I have with insurance Amy is always willing to help me out.

Jim Seery

Nov 24, 2020

Amy Nuttall was extremely helpful. My clients had their new insurance cards within minutes! Great Job. Thank you, Jim

Tracy L Stratton

May 24, 2018

Great place to get auto insurance! Attentive to your needs and very professional! I highly recommend this place. In addition Ms. Amy that works the office was very charming and will give her all to search the best quote for you!

Jennifer Gamble

May 17, 2018

I highly recommend Amy Nuttall for home and car insurance. She saved me over $1,000 a year on my home owner’s insurance and hundreds of dollars on my car insurance. She is friendly, dependable and responds promptly with any questions I may have. Choose Great Florida and Amy Nuttall in St. Augustine!

Dawn Wynn

May 15, 2018

I had been with the same insurance company for 25 years before switching. Amy’s customer service is above the rest always a prompt answer, sometime responding on her own time. Appreciate her and all the guidance she has given along with the money I save.

Jaimie Green

May 14, 2018

After the 2 hurricanes we had in St. Augustine they helped me with insurance for my business! The best thing about the whole process is I never had to go to the office! Everything done via phone email scan! Highly recommend!

Theresa Smith

May 14, 2018

Customer did not leave a comment...

Savannah Nuttall

May 14, 2018

Customer did not leave a comment...

Amy Nuttall

May 03, 2018

Customer did not leave a comment...

Kevin White

Nov 28, 2017

Steve is the best. I've know him for years. His rates are extremely competitive, and he cares that folks are covered properly. I highly recommend doing business with him and his agency.

Joy Burkey

Jul 12, 2016

I've been a customer at this location for many years, and the only reason I have stayed a local customer is because of the excellent customer service. Amy always goes out of her way to make sure I fully understand my options based on my needs. Whenever I can, I recommend this location to my friends and family.